I have driven by the sign in the window that says “Keys Copied Here” a million times and have told myself not to forget about it the next time i needed keys, so when my dad bemoaned the fact that he had to go all the way to the Home Depot to get the house keys copied awhile back, I was happy to pipe in: “You can just go to the Puritan, they do it!”
The Puritan is that unassuming little news/variety store in Noroton Heights, on the corner of the Post Road and Noroton Ave, and yes: they copy keys! They also have a large assortment of Hallmark cards, random toys and gifts, an ice box w/ Good Humor ice cream and other various and sundry items including, of course, newspapers and magazines galore. FYI, they only accept cash — no checks or credit cards! There is an ATM inside the store.